10 Reasons to Adopt a German Shepherd Instead of a Dachshund

Both German Shepherds and Dachshunds are popular dog breeds, but they couldn’t be more different. While Dachshunds are small, playful, and full of personality, German Shepherds are strong, intelligent, and highly trainable. If you’re trying to decide between these two breeds, here are 10 reasons why a German Shepherd might be the better choice for you.

1. German Shepherds Are Highly Intelligent and Trainable

German Shepherds are one of the smartest dog breeds in the world. They are quick learners, eager to please, and excel in obedience training.

Dachshunds, while intelligent, are notoriously stubborn, making training more difficult—especially for first-time dog owners.

Best for: Owners looking for an obedient, easily trainable dog.

2. They Make Excellent Guard Dogs

If security is a priority, a German Shepherd is the better choice. They are natural protectors who will guard their family, home, and property.

Dachshunds, despite their big attitude in a small body, are not strong enough to serve as effective guard dogs. They may bark a lot, but they can’t offer the same level of protection as a German Shepherd.

Best for: People who want a watchdog and protector.

3. German Shepherds Are More Versatile

Few breeds are as versatile as the German Shepherd. They are used as:

• Police dogs
• Search-and-rescue dogs
• Military dogs
• Service and therapy dogs

Dachshunds are primarily companion dogs and don’t have the same level of versatility or work ethic.

Best for: Owners who want a dog that can do it all—from protection to companionship.

4. They Excel at Outdoor Activities and Exercise

German Shepherds are high-energy dogs that love outdoor adventures, including:

• Hiking
• Running
• Agility training

Dachshunds, due to their long backs and short legs, are not built for intense physical activity. They can be prone to injuries if they jump or run excessively.

Best for: Active owners who love outdoor adventures with their dog.

5. They Have a Stronger, More Athletic Build

German Shepherds are powerful and athletic, making them ideal for owners who want a strong, capable dog.

Dachshunds, while charming, have a fragile spine due to their elongated body, making them prone to back injuries (Intervertebral Disc Disease).

Best for: People looking for a robust, athletic dog that can handle rough play and training.

6. German Shepherds Are More Independent

Dachshunds are clingy and needy, often following their owners everywhere. They suffer from separation anxiety and don’t do well when left alone.

German Shepherds, while loyal, are more independent. They can stay home alone for longer periods (with proper training) without becoming destructive.

Best for: Owners who want a dog that is loyal but not overly dependent.

7. They Are Better with Children

German Shepherds are known for their gentle, protective nature around children. They form deep bonds with families and often act as watchful guardians.

Dachshunds, while loving, can be snappy if handled roughly. Their small size and fragile backs make them less suited for homes with young kids who may unintentionally hurt them.

Best for: Families with children who need a reliable, protective dog.

8. They Are Less Prone to Genetic Health Issues

While no breed is free from health problems, German Shepherds generally have fewer breed-specific issues compared to Dachshunds, which suffer from:

• Intervertebral Disc Disease (IVDD) (back problems)
• Patellar luxation (knee dislocation)
• Obesity issues due to their small frame

Best for: Owners looking for a healthier breed with fewer physical limitations.

9. They Have a Longer Attention Span

Dachshunds are known for their short attention spans and stubborn streak, making training and focus difficult.

German Shepherds, on the other hand, have an impressive ability to stay focused on tasks, which is why they excel in obedience training, service work, and complex tasks.

Best for: Owners who want a dog that can pay attention, follow commands, and stay engaged.

10. They Are More Emotionally Attuned to Their Owners

German Shepherds are highly intuitive and emotionally intelligent. They can sense their owner’s moods and often act as natural therapy dogs.

While Dachshunds are affectionate, they are more independent and stubborn, making them less emotionally connected than German Shepherds.

Best for: People looking for a dog that can provide emotional support and companionship.

Should You Choose a German Shepherd or a Dachshund?

Both breeds have their own strengths and unique qualities, but a German Shepherd is the better choice if you’re looking for a:

• Highly intelligent, trainable dog
• Loyal protector and family guardian
• Strong, athletic dog for outdoor adventures
• Dog with fewer health risks
• Emotionally supportive and intuitive companion

Dachshunds, while adorable and full of personality, are more stubborn, fragile, and prone to health issues. If you want a dependable, loyal, and highly capable dog, the German Shepherd is the way to go!